Skip to main content

Goodbye PAS.

The change to the NTU Points Award Scheme (PAS) did not come as a surprise to me. The enrollment has increased steadily with the opening of the new schools (Humanities, Physical Science, Design and Media). The demand for hostels will definitely go up as well. Therefore a revamp of the system is needed, especially to cater for students who live far from the campus. However, I feel the abolishment of points system completely in the new Hall Allocation Scheme (HAS) is not very good move.

Of cuz, the new scheme has its advantages (you can read about it here). The best thing about the new scheme is that students who are staying far from school will worry less about getting up early and travelling so far to campus (unlike SMU or NUS, NTU is situated at this far corner of Singapore!). Students who never have got a chance at hostel life will do so now too. Student leaders will also be rewarded. Locals will also get more chance to stay with international students in the new scheme.

Although they said that ECA participations will not drop, I can only partially agree. As former hostelites, we know that one of the key motivation to join ECA, especially for hall activities. It is also a big incentive for being active in hall activities. I, myself, in particular, believe in joining activities for my own interest and never join much hall activities in my four years in Hall One (except for block/hall supper and a seafood trip to JB). But I don't think there is anything wrong in joining for the sake of points and sincerely appreciate their services in enhancing our hall life (excluding the additional noise lah. =p). Inter-hall games, hall productions, and other hall activities produced many talents in sports and the arts. This will not be possible without the help of many people who worked in the backend to support these talents, due to the ECA points they'll get.

I agree it is good to change our mindset to adapt to the changing world, but we all know that by abruptly abolishing the point system, and not taking the tweaking approach, we patch the existing holes, but also create other holes in the system as well. New students, with no knowledge of the former system, are most likely to take the changes hands down. It is similar to increasing of school fees. They are likely to just accept it. Being more thankful about their fresh new start of life, they will not protest against what the short-change they are not aware of. It is up to those who been through the system to be able to appreciate these changes.

I will prefer they keep the point system but give different levels of bonus points according to the distance students stay away from the campus. Eg. staying at a radius of 10km onwards will entitle the applicant to bonus point. And the further you stay, the more bonus points you'll get. The other conditions for priority in HAS can also be translated to some kinda bonus points. That will take these situations into account. Students with special conditions such as they do not have time to take on ECA as they have to work to support their family, pay for bills etc, should be able to write in and consider of given a place directly.

Without the point system, it will also be difficult to allocate students according to their preference of hall. Hostelites may not be able to stay near each other in the following year as they are allocated to different halls. Will the new system consider the location of the hall and school as well? Eg. allocating students who attend lessons in South spine to Halls near their school, such as Hall 4, 5, 1, etc. Students in PAS can do that by working to their points to stay in halls of their preference.

Although the point system is not perfect, it awards students by merit. It is fairer, and can quantify why a student deserve the room more than another student. The same logic as why we don't do away with examinations. Frederick Douglass once said, "People might not get all they work for in this world, but they must certainly work for all they get."

Quoting from the school, "Reform is a process, not an event". I hope they will continue to consider ways to improve the system, and the new HAS will not be final yet.

Of cuz some may say all these are none of my business lah, since I graduated already. But like I said earlier, it takes someone who has been through the system to really appreciate the system, to know what is not so good, what is better. Thus, I am giving my five cent worth on this issue.

Comments

▐≤¡Γ≡ said…
Erm, wanted to say something, but I think I point to the NTUSU forum better.

http://su.ntu.edu.sg/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=18&PN=1
egeus said…
yeah, i guess they are others who have similar feelings as me too. heh heh.

the ethics of hostelites is a separate issue. hee hee.

Popular posts from this blog

The Bridal Dowry.

The delivery of dowry ( 送嫁妆 ) is another important custom. It represents parent's effort for her daughter to have a good life after marriage and prepare her with the necessities for being a good wife. I am amazed by some of the things included in the dowry. Of course, in our modern living, we will not be using some of those things... Nevertheless, I think it is all good to have them, as each item carries a good meaning for our blissful marriage. :-)

If you have it, just flaunt it.

Its such a lousy day, I have decided to blog another entry. Yesh, I am thinking about things other than my last two papers on Thurs and Friday. Something probably talked alot before by many people... What is it with men and women with 可爱-oooii *杨丞琳's voice* face, long tresses, slim legs, curvey body, in revealing tight clothes (only for those with the former characteristics), in pink. Why are men so attracted to those features? The guy is lying if he says he will not turn his head when he sees women with those features. I think it has nothing to do with men being lustful or anything disgusting. It probably has something to do with the genes, the hormones. I don't believe it has to do with things like its men's nature instinct to look for partners who can reproduce blahblahblah. That's so boring! Its something mysterious, something that let men derives pleasure by just looking openly, without doing anything bad or harmful or immoral. Do women ogle at men all the time too

Dreaming About You.

I usually leave my handphone on during the night (just in case if anyone want to contact me urgently, eg. a friend in need of help etc). But I think I will be leaving my phone off from now on. Why? In the wee hours this morning, I received three continuous sms . I forced myself outta bed to read the message, thinking it must be something very important. I surprised to read that they were messages from " Dreamchat ", telling me that " someone is dreaming of me ". Oh great! What a good reason to wake me up! It also asked me to call this 1900 number to listen to the message. There was even a member id at the end... So someone still wide awake in the middle of the night decided to use this wonderful service to let me know he/she is dreaming of me leh. wah seh. I immediately deleted the messages and went back to sleep. Knowing I will just have a few more hours of my six hours daily sleep time left. How did this " Dreamchat " thingy got my handphone number? Is